How much do you charge for custom cakes?

All of our custom cakes are priced individually. We take into factor the amount of details that are added to your order with buttercream and/or fondant. Please contact us for a specialty custom cake here or call 203-269-9408.

How much do you charge for wedding cakes?

Our buttercream wedding cakes begin at $3.50 per serving and our fondant wedding cakes begin at $4.50 per serving. You may send us more details of what you would like and we can send you over a quote! Fill out a form here, or call us at 203-269-9408

How much extra do you charge for fillings and specialty flavors?

We have classic cake flavors and filling flavors and we have specialty cake flavors and filling flavors. Our classic flavors are included in your price. The specialty prices can be found here


Do you deliver?

Yes, we do deliver! We deliver within a 20 mile radius from the Cakery (156 Center Street)

What is the cost for delivery?

Our delivery is $1.50 per mile round trip (to and from 156 Center Street)

Do you ship your cakes, cupcakes and cakepops?

We regret that we cannot ship any baked goods.

Do you deliver on Sundays or Mondays when you are closed?

We do not deliver on Sundays or Mondays. Orders for these days would need to be picked up or we can deliver on Saturday.

Flavors and Tastings

What cake fillings and flavors do you have?

You can view all of our flavors and fillings here

We love the way your cakes look, but do they taste as good as they look?

All of our orders are baked to order each week. Which means we have no frozen cake/cupcakes here! We use fresh ingredients including milk, flour, sugar, eggs and real butter!

You’re closed on Sundays and my event falls on a Sunday, can I still place an order?

Of course! We make cakes each week for showers or events being held on Sundays. You would pick up or have the order delivered on the Saturday before your event.

Do you offer cake tastings?

We offer cake tastings for weddings only. If you would like to sample our cakes for any other occasion, we sell mini cupcakes at the Cakery for $1.00 with 12-16 flavors each day!
Wedding Tastings: We have tastings by appointment only, call 203-269-9408 to make your appointment! We are available for appointments Tuesdays through Thursdays from 8:00-3:00 and Fridays from 8:00-5:00

What cake flavors and fillings do you have?

Check out our flavors page to see what we have to offer!

I have my own cake flavor in mind, do you make custom flavors?

Definitely! We always love trying new flavors, so if you have something in mind, let us know and we can see what we can do!

Do you make gluten free cakes?

Yes we do! We offer chocolate or vanilla gluten free cakes/cupcakes. You can specialize these cakes/cupcakes more with fillings and different frosting flavors!

Do you make vegan cakes?

We currently offer chocolate or vanilla

Do you make sugar free cakes?

At this time we do not make sugar free cakes.

Do you make dairy free cakes?

We have a dairy free vanilla cake and a dairy free vanilla buttercream frosting!

Are you a nut free bakery?

We are not a nut free bakery. Although we try our best to keep the nuts separate while decorating, we do mix and bake in the same pans as the batters with nuts inside!

Ordering Information

How do I place an order?

You can call 203-269-9408 to place an order or email us at Hello@alyssascakery.com You may also come into the Cakery to place an order, but we do recommend calling ahead and making an appointment and checking our availability as we are busy working on orders each day

How far in advance should I place my order?

We book 2-4 weeks in advance for orders on Fridays-Sundays. If you are interested in placing an order Tuesdays-Thursdays we ask for 1-2 weeks. If it is a last minute order you can definitely give us a call and we can try our best to fit your order into the schedule!

Is a deposit required when placing an order?

A 50% deposit is required when placing an order

What methods of payment do you accept?

We accept cash, checks and any cards except American Express

Do you have a retail store where I can walk in and purchase a cake or cupcakes on the spot?

Yes we do! We are opened Tuesdays-Thursdays 8:00-3:30 Fridays 8:00-6:00 and Saturdays 7:00-2:00. We sell mini and regular sized cupcakes, 6” display cakes, muffins, scones, coffee, mochi icecream and other small items!

Traveling/Caring for Cake

I would like to pick up my order. What should I be prepared for?

If you would like to pick up your cake..
Tiered Cakes:
-Need to travel with absolute safe care! The vehicle it is in needs to be a flat ground surface (can’t be put on the seat or on someone’s lap)
-Driving needs to be slow and steady (can’t go back and forth in the lanes on the highway) When you get to a stop sign or stop light begin slowing down well before to give enough time to not let the car jerk!
-When you arrive at the cakery we can help you put it in your car, but know once you leave the cakery it is out of our hands and we will not be held responsible if something were to happen. We put dowels in each tier to properly hold them up and then one down the entire center so the cake is very sturdy, but remember…it is still delicate!

Contact Us To Get Started